The Video Game Critic

What do you think?

I think it's sort of redundant when you consider we also have the "Now Playing" board, which I always took as on opportunity to post my own reviews. Unless I completely missed the point of that board.

I'd say we should. There's a lot of potential.

I think we should keep the reader review boards. Back in the day these were full of awesome reviews.

Sure the "now playing" thread covers this a bit, but I've always looked at that forum as impressions and whatnot.

I think the board is a good idea. It's interesting to see what other people thought of a game. I think jlh is right that the now playing board is more for quick impressions while this one is more for detailed looks at games.

I think it's settled then! This board stays.

Also, I have two more boards that have been long dormant: Questions and Answers and High Score Challenge.
Maybe we should give these another look too.

I say the more the merrier!

If we could revive a regular high-score challenge board, that would be amazing. I'm also really glad to see reader reviews return as I do a lot of those.