[QUOTE=sega saturn x]Wait we are rating the consoles on how much the media hyped them? That's just retarded, were basing this off games I thought? In that case the wii has ONE great game and that's zelda (I personally think it sucks but hey so has every other zelda.)[/QUOTE]
I can see that we are going to constantly be arguing on whether the Wii's release titles were worth anything. I suggest that they are. Not just Zelda -- I was impressed with Rayman, Excite Truck, Madden 2007, Trauma Center, and Super Monkey Ball. All of those are great games and were within the Wii's launch Window.
Instead of arguing with Rob's scores, why not make a listing of your own with your paragraph reviews for each and a final score?
[QUOTE=Shawn]Elebits was not a launch title. Ok, do I really want to play a videogame of hide and seek? Not really. Madden is good but Need for Speed is better on all of the other systems. I simply do not like the Wii Controller for Racing games, it feels "floaty" at best. Anyway, think what you want.[/QUOTE]
Elebits, Madden, Need for Speed -- all in the launch window. They don't have to be there on launch day to be considered part of the launch. That is why every console developer, including Sony, creates a launch window of anywhere between two and three months.
Sometimes that's not a good thing either. The XBOX launch didn't probably get helped by the fact that Obiwan was released within its launch window. It was one of those games that turned a lot of people off of the system.