Page 1 of 3

2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 10:37 am
by VideoGameCritic
Here's an RPG review from the VGC!
This is a nice game to play before bed - it should help you fall asleep!

Re: 2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 10:53 am
by DaHeckIzDat
Interesting. I haven't played I Am Setsuna yet, but I heard it was modeled heavily off of Chrono Trigger, an RPG you actually liked. What would you say makes them different?

Re: 2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 12:01 pm
by Stalvern
DaHeckIzDat wrote:Interesting. I haven't played I Am Setsuna yet, but I heard it was modeled heavily off of Chrono Trigger, an RPG you actually liked. What would you say makes them different?

Chrono Trigger was a guest review.

Re: 2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 12:28 pm
by Sonicx9
Stalvern wrote:
DaHeckIzDat wrote:Interesting. I haven't played I Am Setsuna yet, but I heard it was modeled heavily off of Chrono Trigger, an RPG you actually liked. What would you say makes them different?

Chrono Trigger was a guest review.

He self reviewed the Nintendo DS version later on, also critic which version of I Am Setsuna physical do you have the Japanese cover: https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com ... SY445_.jpg, or the Asian cover: https://www.gameshome.com.sg/wp-content ... boxart.png which one?

Re: 2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 12:29 pm
by DaHeckIzDat
Stalvern wrote:
DaHeckIzDat wrote:Interesting. I haven't played I Am Setsuna yet, but I heard it was modeled heavily off of Chrono Trigger, an RPG you actually liked. What would you say makes them different?

Chrono Trigger was a guest review.

Not the DS version.

Re: 2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 12:59 pm
by VideoGameCritic
I was emailed by a helpful reader that the save function is available when you are on the world map.
I'll probably add a note to the review, but I still think the save system stinks.

Re: 2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 1:19 pm
by Stalvern
Sonicx9 wrote:He self reviewed the Nintendo DS version later on,

DaHeckIzDat wrote:Not the DS version.

:oops:

Re: 2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 3:43 pm
by GameOfThrones
Given that this is a portable game, the most important thing is to have a save option. You are on the tube and you have 20 minutes to play. You need to be able to save there and then. When it is linked up that is not a problem. For me I would need duality in the save system to allow me the flexibility to use it wherever I was.

For the looks of your review it seems lacking in that department.

Re: 2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 4:06 pm
by ptdebate
VideoGameCritic wrote:Here's an RPG review from the VGC!
This is a nice game to play before bed - it should help you fall asleep!


I have a couple of questions. I have not gotten a chance to play this one yet.

The save system is exactly the same as every other JRPG, from Final Fantasy to Chrono Trigger. The review seems to frame it as unique in some way. Nevertheless, I can understand not liking it.

Do you think the knowledge that you can save anywhere on the overworld would have helped your progress in the game?

Based on the other reviews I’ve read, I thought the battle system was lifted directly from Chrono Trigger. The ATB system you mention is another staple. Given that this game is essentially Chrono Trigger, has your perspective on that game changed as well?

You mention that the game tries to reinvent the wheel. If anything it seems we could fault it for not reinventing anything at all.

Re: 2018/1/27: Nintendo Switch: I Am Setsuna (Japan)

Posted: January 27th, 2018, 4:21 pm
by VideoGameCritic
I complained about Chrono's save system in my DS review, but the original game is 20+ years old so we can cut it some slack.
I wouldn't have affected my progress. If anything, the lack of save points kept me playing long after I had lost interest.

Outside of the lousy save system this feels nothing like Chrono Trigger. The battle system is terrible.
It may have been "based" on the same system, but it is not the same.