Sorry, this is old, but....Yoshi's Island is BAD? Really?? To me, it's my 2nd favorite SNES game. It's an OUTSTANDING game. And Mario Kart absolutely deserves it's A+ by the VGC. It's perfect. It amazes me how many SNES games are truly stellar. To me, these SNES games all deserve A+ ratings:
The Legend of Zelda: A Link To The Past (probably the best video game I've ever played, absolute perfection on all counts)
Super Mario Kart
Super Mario World
Final Fantasy VI
Secret of Mana
As for Super Mario RPG, I loved that game. Nowhere near my favorite RPG game on the SNES (that would be Chrono Trigger and if it counds, LoZ: ALTTP) but it is still a great game. Wonderful graphics, too.
And yeah, I know, I'm just feeding the trolls, I shouldn't take it at all seriously, but I can't help it, I always rush to the defense of my #1 favorite video game console.
The readers post their own reviews.