I'm not sure. I know that my buddy Eric reviewed the PS2 version in another thread, and said it was mediocre at best.
Thanks for calling a spade a spade. This game is crap.
The only oversight I noticed in the review is the lack of criticism for the elimination of coop play. The first thing my friend and I do every year when this game comes out is start a coop dynasty. There is no coop play on the 360. That makes the game completely worthless to me.