The Video Game Critic

That would be a good idea. You for one, could list more games that have excellent multiplayer, and two make it easier to find games that people prefer.  If you split it into head to head and co-op I'd at least consider making it a two player minimum (instead of 4) for co-op.

A little late, but I think it should be called something along the lines of top 25 'offline/local' multiplayer games.

I think this would be a non-intrusive way of making clear one of the Critic's notable skew's.