The Video Game Critic

All I am saying, is, you need to understand that Acid is pretty much a boardgame--or else you are not going to enjoy it. I really liked it, I can see how other people could NOT like it. I could not see it getting an F, unless the person did not understand how to play it completely.
The second one is also better, by the way.

All I am saying, is, you need to understand that Acid is pretty much a boardgame--or else you are not going to enjoy it. I really liked it, I can see how other people could NOT like it. I could not see it getting an F, unless the person did not understand how to play it completely.
The second one is also better, by the way.

[/QUOTE]

Wait, you just said you understand how someone can not like it but you said you couldn't imagine it getting an F.  Don't those things counterdict each other?

You guys just need to get thicker skin and ignore Koopa and Boston. Everyone knew how they'd respond the minute everyone read the post here about the Critic buying a PSP.

I look forward to more reviews. I'd love one with several titles such as the Namco collection, but I just can't afford it yet.

I think its important to bear in mind the Critic's tastes.  I haven't really seen him look positively on any turn based games before (maybe I missed them?) and he doesn't seem to have much in the way of strategy games collection.  So an F from him for this genre doesn't mean that AC!D is such a bad game just that it doesn't appeal to people who don't like strategy games.

I think its important to bear in mind the Critic's tastes.  I haven't really seen him look positively on any turn based games before (maybe I missed them?) and he doesn't seem to have much in the way of strategy games collection.  So an F from him for this genre doesn't mean that AC!D is such a bad game just that it doesn't appeal to people who don't like strategy games.

[/QUOTE]

He gave advanced wars and vandal hearts both A's what are those chopped liver?  Face it card battle games suck, not just ac!d but really any of them.

Like I said in my post maybe I missed them.  But you have to admit they are an under represented genre on here.

And to quote his Vandal Hearts review "I'm not a big RPG/Strategy fan" so my statement still kind of stands.

In real life card battle games are great so I don't see why they would necesarily have to such in electronic form.

Like I said in my post maybe I missed them.  But you have to admit they are an under represented genre on here.

And to quote his Vandal Hearts review "I'm not a big RPG/Strategy fan" so my statement still kind of stands.

In real life card battle games are boring so I don't see why they need to be made in electronic form.

[/QUOTE]

I don't disagree but it shows it isn't him, if a game's high quality he likes it if not well...yeah.

And I fixed your card battle statememnt.