Games the Critic Hasnt Reviewed (that you think he would like)
Tomba - PS1 this game is awesome, and may be the best side scrolling adventure game ever made, if not the only one
Oddworld PS1 - This game is underrated and awesome!!
Hitman Blood Money Xbox 360- This is the best stealth series of all time, I like it much more than Thief, Splinter Cell, or Metal Gear Solid. Blood Money is probably the best of the bunch, so Critic should probably start out with it. It is a lot of fun looking for new ways to take out your targets, and the ability to steal enemy costumes is probably the greatest feature in any game ever. Also it is hillarious whenever people don't notice that the Asian guard you just killed has been replaced with a white bald guy with a barcode on the back of his head. I wonder if the critic has ever heard of this series? 
Paper Mario 2 - Gamecube - I know the critic doesn't like JRPGS very much, but this one is action packed and highly interesting. It is completely different from the average RPG.
Smackdown Know your role -PS2 - This is not a good game. It is a horrible game. You can block almost every single move, and the commentary is the worst commentary in any game I have ever played. But the game is so broken, it is absolutely hillarious to play!
F-Zero GX Gamecube- This is the fastest racing game I ever played!
EVO SNES - An extremely rare game, I bet the critic would have a hard time finding it, but if he could, this is a really fun castlevania style side scroller with RPG elements. Also it is Jerry Falwell's least favorite game because it is about evolution!