velcrozombie wrote:The Portal games are unlike anything else, even if they are technically in the Half-Life universe.
I 100% second this. The cake is a lie. "Apple. No, you jumped again..." Fantastic dialogue and terrific gameplay.
I also want to 2nd C64 Critics comments on Wizardry. It spawned an absolutely massive genre and is one of my favorite old games. I still play Wizardry 8 regularly, and wrote a somewhat longer post on it awhile back. I've always wanted to beat the first one, (and Bard's Tale...) but have never managed it. I never got past the teleporter floor. I tried playing the original on an emulator recently and I leveled up a character and they LOST STATS! Damn that is insanely brutal.
And as for my innovative games selection... That is a tough one, but I'm going to go with Mario RPG. It has so many things, like button mashing, timed hits for attack and defense, and interactive special moves, that would eventually, (FF8 and beyond) start becoming mainstays for the genre. And frankly, playing something like Lost Odyssey on Xbox 360 you see that Mario RPG did timed hits a lot better than some games did 11 years later!
And Mario RPG is still an absolute joy to play through today. Lost Odyssey... ehhh. (Yes I realize that was an odd comparison to draw.)