The Video Game Critic

My Top 50 (and 2 runners up) of all time:

And nary a Zelda in the list, interesting choices.

[QUOTE]52. CarnEvil (I love this twisted classic) [/QUOTE]

That's a joke right?  There is nothing classic about carnevil it's an ugly and cheaply made light gun game.  Clearly this is your own list but carnevil instead of just about any other light gun game is funny.

I posted my top 25 about a year ago.  Only three games overlap on our lists, ha.

You should write a sentence or two about why you like each one.

Uhh... oops. I thought I put Zelda: LTTP in the list. *re reads list* I don't guess I did. In that case, it's tied for 10th. I say tied, because I refuse to redo my list that took 3 hours of my life.

SSX- Chill man. It's just a game, and I thought it was a great one. Whatever happened to "to each his own?

I have never seen a top games of all time list that I have disagreed with more.  No way is pokemon one of the top 10, it's an extremely overrated substandard JRPG.   Chrono Trigger or Final Fantasy Tactics are far better.  Smash TV is definately awesome, but not even close to the greatest game of all time.  It doesn't even have any real level design.   I look at this list and I only notice a handful of games that would be on my list.   Castlevania: Symphony of the Night,  Super Mario 64, Smash TV (But not number 1), Super Mario Bros 3, Viewtiful Joe.  I notice a lot of pre NES  arcade style games on the list, and I'm really not a big fan of them.  Maybe because I'm young, but I just don't feel they have aged well.   Games like Galaga and Pac Man get boring to me very quick.

I notice Splinter Cell on this list.   Ever play any of the Hitman games?  I like them far better than Splinter Cell.

[QUOTE]

SSX- Chill man. It's just a game, and I thought it was a great one. Whatever happened to "to each his own?

 [/QUOTE]

To each his own died when you put carn evil on your list instead of a game that doesn't totally suck.  Especially when you have a list devoid of Time Crisis the best light gun games ever made.

What's so great about Q*bert, I mean seriously, I've played both the platformer and the orignal one and neither impressed me.  Matter of fact before I started hearing people talk about how great they were I just figured it was another failed mascot like Bubsy or Awesome Possum.