Harsh Rating for Nightcaster!!!

[Mephisto]

Dear Dave,

You rated Nightcaster a D... Why? It is a really fun game. The hassle of switching spells to different color monsters makes it way more challenging. Otherwise, you could just blast monsters uncontrollably and it wouldn't ANY fun whatsoever... Anyways switching the spells isn't that much of a hassle you should have to press L or R... The shorter range of spells is sometimes annoying though. I think this game deserves atleast a B-

M

[m0zart1]

Dear Dave,

Nightcasters was terrible.  It deserved the D-.  My only minor complaint is that you didn't give it an F.  Kudos to you for recognizing garbage.

m

[Superjay]

Dear Dave can I have your copy of Nightcaster since you are using it as a coaster now?

[m0zart1]

[QUOTE=Superjay]Dear Dave can I have your copy of Nightcaster since you are using it as a coaster now?[/QUOTE]

Why should he give up a perfectly good coaster?

[Koopa W.]

[QUOTE=Mephisto]
you could just blast monsters uncontrollably
[/QUOTE]

Dear Dave,

I never played the damn game. Who's right? I tend to side with you, the critic, but I'm just wondering.

k

P.S. Now the part I quoted sounds like a damn cool game.

[Astrosmasher1]

[QUOTE=Mephisto]Dear Dave,

You rated Nightcaster a D... Why? It is a really fun game. The hassle of switching spells to different color monsters makes it way more challenging. Otherwise, you could just blast monsters uncontrollably and it wouldn't ANY fun whatsoever... Anyways switching the spells isn't that much of a hassle you should have to press L or R... The shorter range of spells is sometimes annoying though. I think this game deserves atleast a B-

M
[/QUOTE]

You are right VGC gave this the wrong rating .... I think F is nearer the right rating for this absolute stinker...
Did you know they made a sequel which played exactly the same way....

[a1]

Dear Dave,

I've been down lately, and I was hoping to get your advice. You see, I've never played Nightcaster, so I have nothing to contribute to this page. That makes me sad.

                                                                        From,

I wasted your time with this post.

[Astrosmasher1]

[QUOTE=a]Dear Dave,

I've been down lately, and I was hoping to get your advice. You see, I've never played Nightcaster, so I have nothing to contribute to this page. That makes me sad.

                                                                        From,

I wasted your time with this post.

[/QUOTE]

The problem with the game is not that it is a bad game its just that it is a PS1 game.  The graphics are very sub standard for a x box game.  The action is forgettable and samey. 
Part 2 was the same but not quite as good F-.  YOu can buy it for one cent on ebay or you can get the original for 99cents and that is about all it is worth.